If you’re looking for a good laugh to start off the working week, you’d be hard pressed to go past the latest Property report released today by BIS Shrapnel.
According to BIS Shrapnel, real estate prices across Australia are tipped to increase by as much as 20% by 2012.
As reported by news.com.au, BIS Shrapnel’s Angie Zigomanis said activity in the lower end of the market – buoyed by the boost to the first home owners grant and low interest rates – were generating “green shoots” of recovery.
The report says average house prices in most capital cities will grow by between 11 and 19 per cent over the next three years. In real terms (where prices are adjusted for inflation) the level of percentage growth is about half.
Mr Zigomanis, who said actual prices were more indicative than prices adjusted for inflation, predicts the boost to the first home owners grant combined with low interest rates would kick start further activity in the “upgrading” market.
“Kick start further activity in the ‘upgrading’ market?” Really? Based on what exactly? A flight of fancy?
According to BIS Shrapnel, we can expect:
Sydney – Total price growth forecast at 19 per cent to 2012
Melbourne – Nearly 20 per cent increase in prices to 2012
Brisbane – House prices to rise by 16 per cent to 2012
Gold Coast and Sunshine Coast – Expected to grow by 14 per cent to 2011
Adelaide – Tipped to jump 19 per cent to 2012
Perth – House prices to increase by 12 per cent to 2012
Hobart – To jump 15 per cent in the next three years to 2012.
Darwin – To grow by 11 per cent in three years to 2012
To the unititiated, this report would perhaps be the catalyst to “get in quick” before the property boom begins, but the catch cry to “BUY NOW” is beginning to sound all too familiar.
For one thing, it is widely accepted that the FHOG has artificially maintained current property prices at the low-to-mid range of the market. So, on what basis does BIS Shrapnel base their prediction that property prices are going to continue to rise after the FHOG expires?
An environment of rising interest rates and escalating unemployment are hardly factors that would contribute to a real estate property boom.
So what has led to this bizarre prediction? Well, funnily enough BIS Shrapnel’s report has been based on data from the Real Estate Institute – an organisation that has the following mission statement:
“The Institute continues to identify, formulate, encourage and promote public policies that contribute to an economic and political environment favourable to the real estate industry, and small business generally. ”
So not only does this call into question the integrity of the data supplied by the Real Estate Institute to BIS Shrapnel, the fact that the institute is fundamentally concerned with lining the pockets of real estate agents should be ringing alarm bells everywhere.
But not so, the mainstream press just regurgitate the BIS Shrapnel media release without giving it a moment’s worth of critical analysis.
It also makes you wonder about the ethical standards at BIS Shrapnel. But then they did get paid by the Real Estate Institute to write the report, so perhaps in their minds, that’s all that really matters.
A satisfied client.
An invoice paid.
The so called report’s “findings” plastered everywhere in the media.
It would be sickening, if for the fact that it’s all so mind-numbingly predictable.
Filed under: Real Estate/Property | Tagged: BIS Shrapnel, Property Boom, Real Estate Institute, Residential Property Prospects
Speaking of ‘experts’, I couldn’t help noticing the ABC last week switched their go-to guy on all things financial from “Chris Richardson of Access Economics” (I’d like a quid for every time I’ve heard that in the last 12 months) to some guy from the Westpac (whose name I haven’t heard enought to recall – yet).
(Maybe the relatively good economic news of late doesn’t suit Richardson’s doomsaying narrative.)
I’m speechless Reb (wink) I completely agree.
John..am on old bessie the computer and so didn’t have your email address…was of course hoping that you might have time to make a comment or several.
With due regard to above and having absolutely no specific data whatsoever, the above is the most ridiculous piece of twaddle that I have read for a very long time.
Hi Min
I’ve been really bogged down with my case of late and haven’t had much time for anything else. Hopefully, I’ll get a clear direction shortly so I can start planning my life again.
You’re welcome to email me any time
johnmcphilbin@live.com.au
John..you might be sorry..but I’m about to email you.
Hey John! Welcome back
On the subject of real estate, I think I agree with you. Anyone thinking the current economic environment is going to lead to increased property prices is pulling your chain. And if you believe them, I have a bridge that is bound to increase in value once I sell it to you
Ben
Thanks Ben.
I was watching a news piece recently and it focused on a young couple (around 23 years old) who were both working and they they landed a new home for the bargain price of $445K.
She expressed outrage that the banks may start lifting interest rates from their record lows. She said ‘we’ve left a little room for an increase, but not much’. Lets hope one of them don’t lose their jobs or decided to have children anytime soon either.
And now we have BIS forecasting outrageous gains in price. Lets see how many people get the idea that investing in housing for the next 2-3 years is a good idea and when these gains magically manifest themselves they can off-load to some other poor unsuspecting fool for a healthy profit. Joke’s on them though, I’m sure.
I actually believe we are in a very similar RE market to that of 1990 to 1993. The main market (average homes) were generally sluggish but in some areas they boomed. Similar today where the western suburbs of Sydney are stagnant but interest rate falls have allowed a great number of people to stay put A year ago there were for sale signs all over the Liverpool/Campbelltown corridor but then rates began to fall and suddenly there are not that many distressed sales.
Inner Sydney will do quite well with 5 to 7 percent increases but the outer areas will plateau. E.g Look at Erskineville/Newtown. These are becoming the new Paddington/ Surry Hills for Sydney now that its gentrified. Shortly we will begin to see more $1million plus terraces from that area
But BIS Shrapnel are a joke and have been since I can remember.
God damn, a “bargain” of $445K. My wife & I are looking in the $300K range because any higher (on my decent salary) is pushing the limit should interest rates go back up to 8-10% (which they will as the economy manages to get back on track)
G’day, JMc, are you (like me) still waiting for the storm to hit?
The storm will hit but the ordinary people will be the only ones to suffer.
The government has created shelter for the ones that deserve to cop it most!
I don’t dare comment on this thread.
Are you ducking any commentary, migs?
Joni, it’s not the sort of environment to reveal my next property investment. It goes against the grain. It makes me a hated man.
LOL – buying property to rent to WCP (reb and Turnbull)?
MIgs, not sure its just your property acquistion that creates all that hate …?
TB, what’s there to hate?
Shhh..let’s just get friendly with the duck because when we’ve all lost our homes, we can all lob on the doorstep.
Ben
“God damn, a “bargain” of $445K.” Lol I was being sarcastic. My wife came home and told me that one of her customers was telling her that her daughter and son-in-law just got approval for $475K first home loan (excluding what the government’s putting in). Combined salaries of around $110K annually.
BIS have estimate the average house price in Sydney to rise to something like $630K in the next 2 to 3 years, from what I heard on the news (Lol)
Hi TB
Truthfully, I’m more sure than ever that things are going to turn sour, unfortunately. It’s always difficult to time it, however, now that banks have signaled that the only way is up with interest rates – I’d say the pressure is only going to mount. Where did we get the idea that having access to record low interest rates was a good thing?
Ben’s a classic example, his assessment of his ability to meet his obligations and live comfortably within his means, is realistic and sensible. He knows it could really get tough if interest rates rise to a certain level even though he’s pulling in a decent salary
So many people have slim to non-existent ‘margins of safety’ on their loans and sadly increasing numbers of workers who are fortunate to hold a full-time jobs are having their hours cut back substantially, so even if the unemployment figures seem to be holding up well, it doesn’t help people to continue meeting their debt obligations as well as having money to spare to spend and keep the economy ticking over at previous levels.
John, I would keep an eye on the price of crude, I suspect it could be the trigger.
LMAO whilst reading the article on impending property boom.
Here’s what I think of the property market as sung by Malvina Reynolds:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SADPuUYF_4I
And the Lyrics:
Little boxes on the hillside
Little boxes made of ticky tacky
Little boxes, little boxes
Little boxes all the same
There’s a green one and a pink one
And a blue one and a yellow one
And they’re all made out of ticky tacky
And they all look just the same
And the people in the houses all went to the university
Where they all were put in boxes, little boxes all the same
And there’s doctors and there’s lawyers and business executives
And they’re all made out of ticky tacky and they all look just the same
And they all play on the golf course and drink their martini dry
And they all have pretty children and the children go to school
And the children go to summer camp and then to the university
Where they all got put in boxes, and they all came out the same
And the boys go into business and marry and raise a family
In boxes, little boxes, little boxes all the same
There’s a green one, and a pink one
And a blue one and a yellow one
And they’re all made out of ticky tacky
And they all look just the same
God damn! $475K on $110K pa? I’m not going to name my income level, but I’d sure like to know how the hell they got that loan – cos banks are not telling me that’s possible.
Ben
I thought it was a stretch, but my wife insists it’s true and that her customer had similar concerns about the size of the loan.
Maybe your problem is that you’re self-employed perhaps? Or maybe her customer has got it wrong?
Scaper
Perhaps you’re right about crude. My central view is that our economy (with its high level of personal debt and low savings) is fragile. Triggers such as increasing interest rates, unemployment, or increased fuel prices often can act in isolation or in combination to trigger major shifts in consumer spending and debt deflation (i.e. an avalanche of personal and business bankruptcies claims and/ or property foreclosures).
I’ve also noticed that the stock market’s been behaving as though it’s on drugs just recently – it doesn’t know which way to go, which is a reflection of the broader uncertainty, in my opinion.
God damn! $475K on $110K pa?
Piece of piss to get a loan like that. Just don’t mention that you’ve got any credit cards, and they’ll hand that sort of money to you on a silver plate…
Reb
It’s crazy and has been for a while. From last October:
Reb
Lol, it seems all the experts read this post yesterday
House price forecast ‘inaccurate’
http://www.news.com.au/dailytelegraph/money/story/0,26860,25643313-5015795,00.html
The Daily Reckoning has an interesting take on the supposed housing boom and the ‘Buy Australian” campaign being launched by the NSW Government, in its daily newsletter:
I suspect that this UNION led inititiative to buy only Australian, is going to really put pressure on ALP/Union relations in NSW.
A thought..that the only thing that has been keeping the housing market buoyant in recent years has been readily available credit. That is, here is your housing loan and with it, we are offering (wait for it), here is your credit card (not stated of course, but just in case you default).
Just in from Macquarie Bank via Dow Jones Online Services
Macquarie Bank : “We believe it is likely that we are about to return to the ‘big and sharp’ economic cycles of the ’70s and ’80s. If this is correct, this has major implications for the volatility of corporate earnings, particularly cyclicals and equity returns.”
Macquarie continues to expect inventory cycle and extremely positive monetary and fiscal policy to drive “V” shaped global economic recovery. But broker doesn’t expect global economy to return to long duration, low amplitude economic growth. “Rather, the cost of saving the system is likely to see a more volatile economic cycle that is shorter and larger.”
I tend to agree with this as the Credit Markets are a long way from where they were in September last year.
So I dont see a “Storm” coming. More likely a series of “waves” in the forseeable 5 to 6 years. Or a “W” shaped recovery cycle
Maybe even a “Double W” recovery or “WW”………….!
Lol, it seems all the experts read this post yesterday – House price forecast ‘inaccurate’
LOL!! Remember John you heard that it was all bollocks here first!!
Does this mean I need to put the cheque book away?
Migs..hope that you don’t mind but I’ve mentioned your cellar on Victor’s cooking blog at: http://foodtrail.wordpress.com/ ..that is, it’s suitable as cooking wine
Thanks for the laugh Min. Like you, I’m bedridden today and thus a miserable old soul.
I’m bedridden today and thus a miserable old soul.
what makes today any different?
He got a big fright when offered the position of “corporate barista” (tea lady) yesterday.
Consequently, he’s had a sickie.
Hey, maybe we should all bunk in together
I don’t know whether I have the porkie flu (I do not do either dentists or doctors) but have confined self to barracks just in case.
Tom..reminds me of eldest telling us that her b/f was a barrister..and yes she meant, he was a barista.
Min, at least he had a job where he could make a valuable contribution to the community!
Your daughters b/f was able to make an ethical living!!
Reb
Got to admit you made me really proud and I was glad I heard it here first. Lol
Go on. Laugh, make jokes.
Meanwhile I lay here dying.
Meanwhile I lay here dying.
Oh sure. Don’t you mean “meanwhile I lay here filling out workers’ comp forms and flicking through the real estate guide while my servants fix me a cup of lemsip”
Miglo – “Meanwhile I lay here dying.”
Then hurry up, you seem to be taking your time about it.
Tom re daughter’s b/f was able to make an ethical living.
Sadly daughter is now in a long term relationship (the ring being on the finger shortly me thinks) to…a..wait for it..an IT journalist. Where did I go wrong? She could have had a barista and now it’s a…journalist.
Obviously kidding, P* is the sweetest bloke.
Min – “an IT journalist.”
I have a daughter that won’t be ready for boyfriends for about a decade.
I’ll learn from this mistake Min. Perhaps you would share with me where you think you went wrong?
Migs..I think that Tom got you with that one..
And you lot, stop making us sick persons laugh.
John Mcphilbin, on June 15th, 2009 at 9:11 pm
The more I think of it I believe the price of crude could be the trigger.
I have noticed that after the last crude spike prices rose but when the crude price went down the prices stayed high.
It was a gouge, if and when the spike occurs expect another round of price rises and watch the dominoes fall after that.
A good excuse it will be just like the GFC is being used by all and sundry regardless if there is any actual fallout.
A good example is at my wife’s work which is a legal practise and we all know that their business booms at the bottom of the economic cycle.
Still shaking, been on the end of a jackhammer most of the day!
Tom..I always thought, lots of sport, piano lessons and a university education and yet B* has ended up with an IT journo who plays keyboard and who surfs. It was a joke.
This is very obviously kidding re further above, my dad was a factory worker, hubby’s dad drove the baker’s cart (as in a horse).
Yes Min, i was joking.
It is unusual that my comments are acknowledged as such sometimes.
If future son in law surfs, he can’t be too bad.
I would have thought Tom, that you of all people, would derive great pleasure if my demise was slow and painful.
Conceptually you are correct. The imagery is very appealing, you carking it, miserable, in Canberra, with an irrational public servant for a boss, with Port having been thrashed.
Delicious.
The problem is that you keep telling us.
Just get your loved ones to post a draft copy of the death notice please.
*this is an attempt at humour Miglo.
Tom, I get more laughs from the posts where you attempt to be serious.
Tom, thought that it could indeed be humour (hugs).
Where does son in law surf? Down at Bells? It’s certainly double wet suit weather there at the moment.
Migs and I are bunking in together while we have the flu and hubby and Jedda are going to wait on us hand and foot with chicken soup and TB’s toddies until we get well. And given the threat of bunking in together, this should take about 4 minutes. I’ve never seen a duck run so fast!
Miglo – “Tom, I get more laughs from the posts where you attempt to be serious.”
Ummmm, are you suggesting that you think I’ve posted something serious?
Meanwhile….
….that isn’t the Foodtrail, unless you are counting munchies or got lost smoking the catalogues!
Min, I’m pretty familiar with Bells.
So, it is best that I don’t disclose my blogging hobby to anyone I happen to talk to in the surf.
I saw recently (somewhere that I can’t recall right now) that US credit card companies are writing down about 10-12% of their loans, and empowering their frontline customer service agents (i.e. the lowliest tier who man the phones) to cut deals with delinquent customers. They reported on a “typical” case where the customer offered to repay 50% of the outstanding debt and call it quits, and the offer was accepted immediately without requiring approval from a supervisor.
Lotharson
Why don’t I doubt that this is likely to be the case?